Monday, May 7, 2012

Faux-cahontas: Elizabeth Warren's crumbling Native American heritage claims

Leave it to Michael Patrick Leahy, genealogy enthusiast and friend, to blow the lid on Massachusetts presumptive Democratic senatorial candidate and serial exaggerator Elizabeth Warren.


[via American Thinker]

No Credible Evidence for Warren's Claim to Native American Ancestry

Now, decades after Ms. Warren first began making these unsubstantiated claims about her Native American heritage, Chris Child, a researcher at the New England Genealogical Office, has offered one bit of evidence that some claim support Ms. Warren's contention that she has Cherokee heritage. But it's not much.

Mr. Child found that Ms. Warren’s great-great-grandfather, Preston Crawford, had a brother, William Crawford. In 1894, when William Crawford was about 57 years old, he submitted a marriage application to the officials of Logan County, in what was then Oklahoma Territory. In that application, William Crawford stated he wished to receive a license to marry Mary Long, and he further stated that his mother, O.C. Sarah Smith, was a Cherokee.

Here's the problem with that evidence: Nowhere do the records of that time support William Crawford's claim.
It gets worse...
But under the best case scenario for Ms. Warren, her great-great-great grandmother O.C. Sarah Smith was only half Cherokee and half Swedish, making her not 1/32 Cherokee, as most press reports have stated, but 1/64 Cherokee.

However, it is more likely that O.C. Sarah Smith had no Cherokee heritage.

Census records that listed O.C. Sarah Smith Crawford (her married name) as a resident of Tennessee in 1830, 1840, and 1860 classify her as white, not Indian.
I'm not sure which is worse, that Warren has misrepresented herself  for career advancement or that in the year 2012 we still live in a world where career advancement is influenced by race or gender rather than strictly by merit.

Or maybe the worst part is trying to take seriously the Democrats...


[Via Instapundit]


Welcome new readers! Stick around and check out The Wolf Files and my columns in The Washington Times.